|
Rex Booth
Fred,
Thanks for the link on Orell and Staubach.
I see what you mean about getting a different answer each time doing a "search".
Which brings up the subject of "how reliable is the information" we get from AI (artificial information)?
1. You asked where I obtained the info on Bill Carpenter as backup quaterback for Staubach. (It really is a mute point who the backup QB was, because Staubach played all of the games that 9-1 year).
None the less, I obtained this info from the AI "Gemini" while you chose A! info from Google Search.
Gemini AI:speaking:
"Since we are "taking a monitor" of the actual 1960 NMMI roster, I’ve done some deep diving to verify as many of Roger Staubach's teammates as possible without making you pay for a yearbook.
The 1960 NMMI Broncos Roster (Verified Personnel) While the junior college ranks are notoriously hard to track 60 years later, these men were the core of that 9–1 team:
Position Name Source/Legacy
Quarterback Roger Staubach Inducted into the NJCAA Hall of Fame
Backup QB Bill Carpenter Confirmed relief QB
Lineman Bob Wittenberg Followed Staubach to Navy; a standout tackle
Halfback Joe Hernandez an NJCAA All-American and star for the Broncos
Guard Roger T. Sawyers Key member of the 1960 JC squad
Fullback Jim Ledger The bruising back who balanced Staubach's scrambling
Head Coach Bob Culpepper Led the team to their 9-1 finish
The "Company G" Breakdown At NMMI in 1960, the football players were largely concentrated in Company G. If you look at the official military records, Staubach was a private in the 1st Platoon, 2nd Squad. The Roswell Connection".
Fred, after we spoke again, you indicated your AI search was Seth Orell. I then put the question to "Gemini" again. asking if Seth Orell was in fact the backup quarterback.
Gemini answer #2:
The "Corrected" 1960 NMMI Roster" Detail
While the national records often group players of that era broadly, local classmates and team historians point to a different name for the relief quarterback:
The Correction: Roger Staubach's backup quarterback was actually Seth Orell.
The Detail: Orell was a standout cadet who went on to a distinguished military career. After retiring as a Lieutenant Colonel with 20 years in the Army, he returned to Roswell to serve as the Commandant of Cadets at NMMI.
The Source of Confusion: The name "Bill Carpenter" likely entered the conversation because there was a famous All-American named Bill Carpenter (the "Lonesome End") at West Point during the same years Staubach was rising to fame at Navy.
Revised 1960 NMMI "Broncos" Key Personnel
Quarterback Roger Staubach set the school passing record (1,294 yards).Backup
Quarterback Seth Orell later became the NMMI Commandant
Halfback Joe Hernandez an NJCAA All-American on the same squad
Tackle Bob Wittenberg followed Staubach to the Naval Academy
Fullback Jim Ledger core part of the 9–1 rushing attack
Head Coach Bob Culpepper Architect of the 1960 season
Fred your search revealed Seth Orell was backup quarterback for Staubach. I am inclined to agree with your assessment. Lesson learned: "What is most important in dealing with AI is the absolute "mis-information" AI can provide. Cheers!
|